Article Description
Scientific Insights from the Greater Good Gratitude Summit Over the past two decades, the number of published scientific studies of gratitude has exploded, said University of California, Davis, psychologist Robert Emmons at the start of the Greater Good Gratitude Summit on June 7, 2014. Today, he said, we know from this research that saying “thank you” increases happiness, improves relationships, and even lowers your blood pressure and strengthens your heart. The Greater Good Science Center has been fueling the growth of that knowledge through its Expanding the Science and Practice of Gratitude program, which for three years has underwritten the work of 29 scientists and graduate students—many of whom shared their cutting-edge insights with the audience of more than 600 people who attended the Gratitude Summit in-person and on-line. Robert Emmons opens the Greater Good Gratitude Summit. Funded by the John Templeton Foundation and run in collaboration with UC Davis, this research is exploring topics that range from the neuroscience of gratitude to the role of gratitude in romantic relationships to how gratitude might reduce bullying. Here are some highlights from the Greater Good Gratitude Summit, with photographs by Auey Santos. The spiritual side of gratitude Brother David Steindl-Rast and Jack Kornfield say “thank you” to the audience of the Gratitude Summit. Long before science tried to understand why and how gratitude works, spiritual leaders fostered gratitude through teachings and ritual. Thus it seemed appropriate to start the Gratitude Summit with a conversation between Benedictine monk Brother David Steindl-Rast and world-renowned Buddhist psychologist Jack Kornfield. Brother David posed a mystery: Why do some people with many troubles also have great joy, while others with few problems are miserable? The difference, he argued, is gratitude. “That joy that doesn’t depend on what happens,” he said, “is the joy that springs from gratefulness.” Kornfield reflected on how gratitude is what helps us to change for the better through difficult or even terrible experiences. “We are vulnerable to one another and to the vicissitudes of life,” he said. “But what spirit we bring to that vulnerability or to the brokenness or to the difficulties . . . becomes a place also that transforms, that changes us in some profound way.” Brother David imagined how it would change society if this attitude—gratitude in the midst of difficulty—became widespread. In our society, he said, “Whenever your heart is filled and filled and just wants to overflow with thanksgiving and joy, there comes advertising, which tells you, ‘No, no, there is a better model and your neighbor has a bigger one.’” Gratitude, he said, is the antidote to the problems that come with consumer society—a point later echoed at the Gratitude Summit by psychologist Thomas Gilovich. How gratitude changes our bodies Wendy Mendes of the University of California, San Francisco, explains her research into the effects of gratitude on health and aging. In the first panel of scientists, Christina M. Karns of the University of Oregon explored the impact of gratitude on the brain. Her experiments so far have found that gratitude is linked to cognitive control and rewards systems of the brain—and that feeling gratitude compels us to give back. Wendy Mendes of the University of California, San Francisco, explained her research into what biological pathways, like the neuropeptide oxytocin or the Vagus nerve, lead from gratitude to its well-studied health benefits. Their studies are ongoing, and they have not yet published results. But the next panelist, psychiatrist Jeff Huffman, was able to describe the daily impact of gratitude in his work at Massachusetts General Hospital. “Every day, I get to see the powerful effects of gratitude on people in the cardiology wards and on people in our psychiatric units,” he said. He is finding that in the first few weeks after a heart attack, grateful people are more likely to take medications and regularly exercise. In work with psychiatric patients, his team also tested the effects of gratitude practices against other research-based practices, and they are finding that fostering gratitude is by far the most effective way to limit suicidal thoughts. The trouble with gratitude Thomas Gilovich explores the “enemies of gratitude.” The second scientific panel saw some sparks fly between participants. It started with a bracing presentation from Cornell psychologist Thomas Gilovich about the “two enemies of gratitude”: 1) The headwinds/tailwinds asymmetry. That is, our tendency to see the things that are holding us back more clearly than the good things that are pushing us forward—a concept known elsewhere as “negativity bias.” The solution, according to Gilovich, is to tell a story about overcoming headwinds, which fosters gratitude. 2) The remarkable power of adaptation. This is the simple notion that we tend to get used to things, which often renders the good things invisible. The very act of expressing gratitude helps overcome adaptation, suggested Gilovich. He also discussed studies that find experiences foster gratitude, while acquiring possessions actually seems to discourage it, in part because it’s so much easier to get used to stuff and take stuff for granted. Gilovich closed his presentation with a political argument. The American economy and culture, he said, tends to emphasize expanding consumption and acquiring possessions over having the kinds of powerful experiences that foster gratitude: It’s governments that provide an experiential infrastructure. You can’t have these kinds of gratifying experiences—you can’t go out bike riding or hiking if there are no trails, you can’t have gratifying experiences at the beaches or national parks if they’re all falling apart. The experiential infrastructure is decaying, there’s no question about it, and therefore one message of this research that I hope you all take with you is to remember it at the ballot box. We do need to invest in our experiential infrastructure. After Gilovich, social psychologist Amie Gordon and University of Stirling researcher Alex Wood talked about times when gratitude can become problematic, often because the person expressing gratitude has less personal or social power than the person who receives it, as in an abusive relationship—or because gratitude gets taken to unhealthy extremes. “There is no such thing that is good for everyone at all times in all settings,” said Wood. In an impromptu response, Robert Emmons disagreed with all three panelists. “I heard a lot of things that are interesting and provocative,” he said, “but also I heard a lot of things that I disagree with, that I think are flat-out incorrect.” For example, can you be too grateful, as Gordon suggested? Emmons argued that the evidence to date on positive emotions says you cannot. He also argued that the strongest barrier to gratitude is not, for example, a consumer society, as Gilovich suggested, but instead “the self, is me.” When gratitude becomes a “self-development project,” its benefits decline—because it becomes about ourselves instead of other people. Who is right? Video from the Gratitude Summit will soon be available, and you’ll be able to decide for yourself who was most persuasive. Gratitude in the real world Chris Murchinson, vice-president of staff development and culture at HopeLab, talks about fostering gratitude on the job. The Gratitude Summit also featured speakers who talked about applying gratitude to success in daily domains like the family and the workplace. Teri McKeever, coach of the 2012 U.S. Olympic women’s swimming team, talked about fostering gratitude in athletics. Since gratitude strengthens relationships, in part by revealing interdependency, it makes sense that fostering “thank you” would help build team spirit. “If you take a moment before practice to think about what you’re grateful for, and hear your teammates also express their gratitude, I guarantee those practices are always more productive and more cohesive,” she said. Sara B. Algoe, Andrea Hussong, and Giacomo Bono all discussed fostering gratitude in couples and families. Based on her research, Hussong recommended that parents think about gratitude in their children as “more than showing good manners”—as a “process that begins by being aware of the gifts you receive,” in order to increase their sense of meaning. Chris Murchinson, vice-president of staff development and culture at HopeLab, a company that harnesses “the power and appeal of technology to improve human health and well-being,” talked about putting gratitude to work in his company. “I like to think about the workplace as soil, as Earth,” he said. We can add gratitude, compassion, and empathy to the soil, he argued, in order to help grow a positive work environment and to help people express “their best selves.” And yet, pointed out Murchinson, a study from the John Templeton Foundation found that people are less likely to express gratitude on the job than anywhere else. Murchinson described HopeLab employees taking small steps like writing appreciative haikus for each other, and taking big steps, like ditching performance reviews for a conversation that helps the employees explore what they appreciate about their jobs and coworkers. UC Berkeley psychologist and GGSC co-founder Dacher Keltner closed the Gratitude Summit by thanking everyone who made the day possible, from the volunteers to the funders—but especially the scientists. “It takes a lot of courage to study something that science might be skeptical of,” he said. “They’re all breaking new ground.” GGSC Science Director Emililiana Simon-Thomas and her mother share a hug during the Gratitude Summit.
New Insights from the Greater Good Gratitude Summit Over the past two decades, the number of published scientific studies of gratitude has exploded, said UC Davis psychologist Robert Emmons at the start of the Greater Good Gratitude Summit on June 7, 2014. Today, he said, we know from this research that saying “thank you” increases happiness, improves relationships, and even lowers your blood pressure and strengthens your heart. The Greater Good Science Center is fueling the growth of that knowledge through its Expanding the Science and Practice of Gratitude initiative, which for three years has underwritten the work of 29 scientists and graduate students—many of whom shared their cutting-edge insights with the audience of 600 people that attended the Gratitude Summit in-person and on-line. Robert Emmons opens the Greater Good Gratitude Summit. Funded by the John Templeton Foundation and run in collaboration with UC Davis, this research is exploring topics that range from the neuroscience of gratitude to the role of gratitude in romantic relationships to how gratitude might reduce bullying. Here are some highlights from the Greater Good Gratitude Summit, with photographs by Auey Santos. The spiritual side of gratitude Brother David Steindl-Rast and Jack Kornfield say “thank you” to the audience of the Gratitude Summit Long before science tried to understand why and how gratitude works, spiritual leaders fostered gratitude through the teachings and ritual. Thus is seemed appropriate to start the Gratitude Summit with a conversation between Benedictine monk and author Brother David Steindl-Rast and world-renowned psychologist, author, and Buddhist teacher Jack Kornfield. Brother David posed a mystery: Why do we see some people with many troubles also have great joy, while others with few problems are miserable? The difference, he argued, is gratitude: “That joy that doesn’t depend on what happens is the joy that springs from gratefulness.” Kornfield reflected on how gratitude is what helps us to change for the better through difficult or even terrible experiences. “We are vulnerable to one another and to the vicissitudes of life,” he said. “But what spirit we bring to that vulnerability or to the brokenness or to the difficulties…becomes a place also that transforms, that changes us in some profound way.” Brother David imagined how it would change society if this attitude—gratitude in the midst of difficulty—became widespread. In our society, he said, “Whenever your heart is filled and filled and just wants to overflow with thanksgiving and joy, there comes advertising, which tells you, ‘No, no, there is a better model and your neighbor has a bigger one.’” Gratitude, he said, is the antidote to the problems that come with consumer society—a point later echoed at the Gratitude Summit by psychologist Thomas Gilovich. How gratitude changes our bodies Wendy Mendes of the University of California, San Francisco explains her GGSC-sponsored research into the effect of gratitude on health and aging. In the first panel of scientists, Christina M. Karns of the University of Oregon explored the impact of gratitude on the brain. Her experiments so far have found that gratitude is tied up in cognitive control and rewards system of the brain—and that feeling gratitude compels us to give back. Wendy Mendes of UC San Francisco explained her research into what biological pathways, like the neuropeptide oxytocin or the Vagus nerve, lead from gratitude to its well-studied health benefits. Their studies are on-going, and they have not yet published results. But the next panelist, psychiatrist Jeff Huffman, was able to describe the daily impact of gratitude in his work at Massachusetts General Hospital “Every day, I get to see the powerful effects of gratitude on people in the cardiology wards and on people in our psychiatric units,” he said. He is finding that in the first few weeks after a heart attack, grateful people are more likely to take medications and regularly exercise. His team also tested gratitude interventions against others with psychiatric patients, and they are finding that fostering gratitude is by far the most effective way to limit suicidal thoughts. The trouble with gratitude Thomas Gilovich explores the “enemies of gratitude.” The second scientific panel saw some sparks fly between participants. It started with a bracing presentation from Cornel psychologist Thomas Gilovich about the “two enemies of gratitude”: The headwinds/tailwinds asymmetry: That is, our tendency to see the things that are holding us back more clearly than the good things that are pushing us forward—a concept known elsewhere as “negativity bias.” The solution, according to Gilovich, is to tell a story about overcoming headwinds, which fosters gratitude. The remarkable power of adaptation: This is the simple notion that we tend to get used to things, which often renders the good things invisible. The very act of expressing gratitude helps overcome adaptation, suggested Gilovich. He also discussed studies that find experiences foster gratitude, while acquiring possessions actually seems to discourage it, in part because it’s so much easier to get used to stuff and take stuff for granted. Gilovich closed his presentation with a political argument. The American economy and culture, he said, tends to emphasize expanding consumption and acquiring possessions over having the kinds of powerful experiences that foster gratitude: It’s governments that provide an experiential infrastructure. You can’t have these kinds of gratifying experiences—you can’t go out bike riding or hiking if there are no trails, you can’t have gratifying experiences at the beaches or national parks if they’re all falling apart. The experiential infrastructure is decaying, there’s no question about it, and therefore one message of this research that I hope you all take with you is to remember it at the ballot box. We do need to invest in our experiential infrastructure. After Gilovich, social psychologist Amie Gordon and University of Stirling researcher Alex Wood talked about times when gratitude can become problematic, often because of the person expressing gratitude has less personal or social power than the person who receives it, as in an abusive relationship—or because gratitude gets taken to unhealthy extremes. “There is no such thing that is good for everyone at all times in all settings,” said Wood. In an impromptu response, Robert Emmons disagreed with all three panelists. “I heard a lot of things that are interesting and provocative,” he said, “but also I heard a lot of things that I disagree with, that I think are flat-out incorrect.” For example, can you be too grateful, as Gordon suggested? Emmons argued that the evidence to date on positive emotions says you cannot. He also argued that the strongest barrier to gratitude is not, for example, a consumer society, as Gilovich suggested, but instead “the self, is me.” When gratitude becomes a “self-development project,” its benefits decline—becomes it becomes about ourselves instead of other people. Who is right? Video from the Gratitude Summit will soon be available, and you’ll be able to decide for yourself who was most persuasive. Gratitude in the real world Chris Murchinson, vice-president of staff development at HopeLab, talks about fostering gratitude on the job. The Gratitude Summit also featured speakers who talked about applying gratitude to success in daily domains like the family and the workplace. Teri McKeever, coach of the 2012 U.S. Olympics women’s swimming team, talked about fostering gratitude in athletics. Since gratitude strengthens relationships, in part by revealing interdependency, it makes sense that fostering “thank you” would help build team spirit. “If you take a moment before practice to think about what you’re grateful for, and hear your teammates also express their gratitude, I guarantee those practices are always more productive and more cohesive,” she said. Sara B. Algoe, Andrea Hussong, and Giacomo Bono all discussed fostering gratitude in couples and families. Based her research, Hussong recommended that parents think about gratitude in their children as “more than showing good manners”—as a “process that begins by being aware of the gifts you receive,” in order to increase their sense of meaning. Chris Murchinson, vice-president of staff development at HopeLab—a company that harnesses “the power and appeal of technology to improve human health and well-being”—talked about putting gratitude to work in his company. “I like to think about the workplace as soil, as Earth,” he said. We can add gratitude, compassion, and empathy to the soil in order to help things grow and help people to express “their best selves.” And yet, pointed out Murchinson, a study from the John Templeton Foundation found that people are less likely to express gratitude on the job than anywhere else. Murchinson described HopeLab employees taking small steps like writing appreciative haikus for each other, and taking big steps, like ditching performance reviews for a conversation that helps the employees explore what they appreciate about their jobs and coworkers. UC Berkeley psychologist and GGSC co-founder Dacher Keltner closed the Gratitude Summit by thanking everyone who made the day possible, from the volunteers to the funders—but especially the scientists. “It takes a lot of courage to study something that science might be skeptical of,” he said. “They’re all breaking new ground.” GGSC Science Director Emililiana Simon-Thomas and her mother share a hug during the Gratitude Summit.
Troubling study finds sharp increase in deaths from painkillers The number of deaths involving commonly prescribed painkillers is higher than the number of deaths by overdose from heroin and cocaine combined, according to researchers at McGill University. In a first-of-its-kind review of existing research, the McGill team has put the spotlight on a major public health problem: the dramatic increase in deaths due to [...]
A new twist on neuro disease: Discovery could aid people with dystonia, Parkinson’s and more Twist and hold your neck to the left. Now down, and over to the right, until it hurts. Now imagine your neck – or arms or legs – randomly doing that on their own, without you controlling it. That’s a taste of what children and adults with a neurological condition called dystonia live with every [...]
Brain imaging shows enhanced executive brain function in people with musical training A controlled study using functional MRI brain imaging reveals a possible biological link between early musical training and improved executive functioning in both children and adults, report researchers at Boston Children’s Hospital. The study, appearing online June 17 in the journal PLOS ONE, uses functional MRI of brain areas associated with executive function, adjusting for socioeconomic [...]
Study links APC gene to learning and autistic-like disabilities Autistic-like behaviors and decreased cognitive ability may be associated with disruption of the function of the Adenomatous Polyposis Coli (APC) gene. When Tufts researchers deleted the gene from select neurons in the developing mouse brain, the mice showed reduced social behavior, increased repetitive behavior, and impaired learning and memory formation, similar to behaviors seen in [...]
How To Predict Whether Your Partner Will Cheat On You Congratulations, you're in love! And will it last? Here's an unusual angle on that high-stakes question.
How to Create Lasting Happiness Is happiness something we are born with or something we need to chase after? Is it bestowed upon us or is it something we must deliberately pursue? Chasing happiness is like chasing a rainbow. We’re never going to catch it. And waiting for it to fall into our lap is as...
Can You Tell the Cat Lovers From the Dog Lovers? We use our personal intelligence to figure out the people around us–often by collecting clues to their personalities. Whether a person loves cats, dogs, turtles or snakes provides information about them.
When Depression Lies & You Feel Like a Failure Anybody who’s grappled with depression knows this: depression lies (or hashtag #depressionlies if you prefer). It tells us the sweet, seductive story that our life is bleak, without hope and therefore, without meaning. But perhaps nobody knows this more than people who head up a company and are responsible for...
What Happens When Mothers Don't Feel Motherly? Mothers are supposed to feel a certain way. They don't always. Part of that spectrum is called Post-Partum Depression. Is there another end to that spectrum that isn't pathological?
Coping with Reunions: A User's Guide to Facing the Yearbook Look up people you feel guilty about. Come to terms with the fact that the kid who smelled funny is now the CEO of a software company with a larger annual budget than that of the Dominican Republic. Realize a lack of intimacy with you in no way seems to have unduly bothered any of your former classmates. Surprise yourself by feeling relieved rather than resentful. Have fun
How to Sniff Out a Pickup Artist Pickup artists lurk about in all sorts of places. Whether it’s the neighborhood bar or on public transportation, by a male or female, you may be the target of people who hide their true intentions. It’s important to learn how to spot, and resist, their efforts to seduce you.
Is There Any Romance in Your Romance? Couples often tell us that they have lost the magical feeling they once knew in their relationship. They want to reclaim the romantic charge that they once shared during the early days of their relationship. Most of us will recall those early years as emotionally challenging and spiritually draining but full...
Bipolar II: A History of Insomnia & Being Traumatized One of the symptoms of Hypomania (Bipolar II) is trouble sleeping. Fierce insomnia can torment the mind, burn the eyes, and interrupt the daily life of an individual. Even with medication, an individual that suffers from hypomania will have an acute memory of the history prior to medication that can...
3 Myths about Managing Bipolar Disorder A common myth about bipolar disorder is that you need to experience a depressive episode in order to be diagnosed with the illness, according to Kelli Hyland, M.D., a psychiatrist in outpatient private practice in Salt Lake City, Utah. However, a person only needs to experience a hypomanic or manic...
Boost for dopamine packaging protects brain in Parkinson's model An increase in the protein that helps store dopamine, a critical brain chemical, led to enhanced dopamine neurotransmission and protection from a Parkinson's disease-related neurotoxin in mice in a recent study. Dopamine and related neurotransmitters are stored in small storage packages called vesicles by the vesicular monoamine transporter (VMAT2). When released from these packages dopamine can help regulate movement, pleasure, and emotional response.
New compound to treat depression identified A compound, hydroxynorketamine (HNK), has been identified by researchers that may treat symptoms of depression just as effectively and rapidly as ketamine, without the unwanted side effects associated with the psychoactive drug, according to a study. Interestingly, use of HNK may also serve as a future therapeutic approach for treating neurodegenerative disorders such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases, the authors note.
This Summer, We Owe Our Veterans an Honest Look Summer is the season we honor our veterans. There’s Memorial Day and the 4th of July, but even beyond these holidays, a summer filled with barbecues and Slip n’ Slides is a time to appreciate the life our country offers and remember the veterans who make it possible. This summer...
Survey of Grown Unschoolers II: Going on to College Most people in our culture believe that college admission requires 13 years of hard work in school, maybe accompanied by frequent tears. To some of them it may be disturbing to learn that it is possible to go to college, and do well there, with no K-12 schooling at all, just by following your own interests and dreams. Here are the words of some who did just that.